Assignment 1 Rubric

Area A+ A A- B+ B B- C+/C C- D/E
System Description This it the introduction which includes the description of the system, the business objectives and stakeholders. This also has the model overview mapping out the system. Outstanding description and communication of the project. Exceptionally clear and well written and presented An excellent description which covers all the relevant details, the maps / description of the system is clear. Stakeholders concerns are clearly identified and well presented. Justification for a business case is very well described. Excellent description in most respects. Excellent mapping of cases/ description of the system in most cases. Very Good description. Very Good mapping of cases/ description of the system. Good description. Good mapping of cases / description of the system. Good description overall. Good mapping of cases/ description of the system overall Satisfactory description. Satisfactory mapping of cases/ description of the system. Adequate description. Adequate mapping of cases/ description of the system. Poor / Well below description without overview or clear stakeholder information
Personas These are the personas that have been generated for the project. They need to reflect the relevant users of the system Outstanding justification and demonstration of research into persona development Excellent personas with clear reasons for the characteristics and excellent coverage Excellent personas in most respects with clear reasons for the characteristics and excellent coverage Very good personas with clear reasons for the characteristics and very good coverage Good personas, with good coverage Good personas overall, with good coverage overall Satisfactory personas are too generic and not clearly justified Adequate persona description and coverage with adequate justification Poor / Well below personas without clear description or reason
Scenarios These are the use cases and journey maps that were selected to be expanded. They cover the core area of functionality Outstanding well-presented use cases, with both clear overview and detail. Clear User Journeys Excellent use case descriptions. The order is justified. Presented at the right level Excellent use case descriptions in most respects. The order is justified. Presented at the right level Very good use case descriptions. The order is justified. Presented at the right level Good use case descriptions. The order is lacking in definition, order or coverage Good use case descriptions overall. The order is lacking in definition, order or coverage and some are missing Satisfactory use case descriptions and scenarios. Adequate use case descriptions and scenarios. Poor / Well below use case descriptions and scenarios.
Reflection This is where the student reflects on what they have learnt from the persona generation task, the task creation, and thinking about the system as a whole. Outstanding deep analysis of learning and understanding of the role of Design thinking Excellent understanding of the learning objectives and reflection on what has been learnt Excellent understanding of the learning objectives and reflection on what has been learnt in most respects Very good understanding of the learning objectives and reflection on what has been learnt Good understanding of the learning objectives and reflection on what has been learnt Good understanding overall of the learning objectives and reflection on what has been learnt. Satisfactory understanding of the learning objectives and reflection on what has been learnt, missing some analysis or understanding of the role of the parts of the assignment Adequate understanding of the learning objectives and reflection on what has been learnt, minimal content, mostly just saying what was done with no thought about what was learnt Poor / Well below understanding of the learning objectives and reflection on what has been learnt, No real reflection and does not show any learning. Comments on student work without context