Project Part 1 Rubric

Area A+ A A- B+ B B- C+/C C- D/E
Design Review
This is the reviewing of the designs that come into the group
Outstanding reviewing. Used the tools very well, justified the use of the tool and found all major issues Excellent reviewing. Used the tools outstandingly well, justified the use of the tool and found all major issues Excellent reviewing in most respects. Used the tools excellently, justified the use of the tool and found most major issues Very good reviewing coverage. Used the tools very good, justified the use of the tool and found some major issues Good reviewing coverage. Used the tools very good, justified the use of the tool and found some major issues Good reviewing coverage in most respects. Used the tools good, and found only some major issues Satisfactory reviewing coverage. Used the tools satisfactorily, and minimal review of previous projects Adequate reviewing coverage. Used the tools adequately, poor or missing most of review Poor / Well below reviewing coverage. No reviews found
Prototype
This is the first full design of the interface for user testing. With a description similar to assignment 2, but updated to include input from the group. All the interactions fleshed out
Outstanding prototype, visual appearance outstanding with wide coverage Excellent prototype, visual appearance excellent with wide coverage Excellent prototype in most respects, visual appearance excellent with wide coverage Very good prototype. Very good coverage and very well designed Good prototype with some areas covered Good prototype in most respects with some areas covered Satisfactory prototype Adequate prototype Poor / Well below standard prototype
Video
Short video of the prototype
Outstanding video with outstanding production value, voice-over or text to explain what is happening clear progression thorough the app and focuses on relevant parts of the prototype Excellent video with excellent production value, voice-over or text to explain what is happening clear progression thorough the app and focuses on relevant parts of the prototype Excellent video in most respects with excellent production value, voice-over or text to explain what is happening and clear progression thorough the app and focuses on relevant parts of the prototype Very good video, useful for understanding the prototype and explains the parts Good video, useful for understanding the prototype and explains some of the parts Good video in most respects, useful for understanding the prototype and explains some of the parts Satisfactory video Adequate video Poor / Well below standard video
Reflection
Reflection on the merging of the designs and the current prototype
Outstanding reflection on the learning from the merging of designs. Understanding of compromises and value of merging. Identifies the best and worst parts of the prototype. Recognition of limitations of the prototype Excellent reflection on the learning from the merging of designs. Understanding of compromises and value of merging. Identifies the best and worst parts of the prototype. Recognition of limitations of the prototype Excellent reflection in most respects on the learning from the merging of designs. Understanding of compromises and value of merging. Identifies the best and worst parts of the prototype. Recognition of some limitations of the prototype Very good reflection on the learning from the merging of designs. Understanding of compromises and value of merging. Identifies some parts of the prototype. Recognition of some limitations of the prototype Good reflection on the learning from the merging of designs. Understanding of compromises and value of merging is limited. No recognition of limitations of the prototype Good reflection in most respects on the learning from the merging of designs. Understanding of compromises and value of merging is limited. No recognition of limitations of the prototype Satisfactory reflection Adequate reflection Poor / Well below standard reflection